Who is the Best Goalkeeper in 2017: An In-Depth Analysis of the Top Contenders

Who is the Best Goalkeeper in 2017: An In-Depth Analysis of the Top Contenders

The year 2017 was a whirlwind of incredible saves, commanding performances, and goalkeeping masterclasses across the globe. For many football enthusiasts, myself included, the question of "Who is the best goalkeeper in 2017?" is more than just a casual debate; it's a deep dive into the psychology, skill, and sheer nerve required to stand as the last line of defense. I remember vividly watching a particularly electrifying match that year, where a single, gravity-defying save in the dying minutes snatched victory from the jaws of defeat. That moment, more than any other, solidified for me the immense importance of a truly world-class goalkeeper. It’s not just about stopping shots; it’s about leadership, anticipation, and the ability to inspire confidence in the entire team. In 2017, several titans of the goalkeeping world were vying for that top spot. This wasn't a clear-cut race with one runaway winner; rather, it was a nuanced discussion involving goalkeepers who demonstrated consistent excellence, made game-changing interventions, and often, carried their teams through difficult moments. To truly answer who was the *best* goalkeeper in 2017, we need to move beyond simple statistics and delve into the qualitative aspects of their performances. We’ll be examining their impact on their respective clubs and national teams, their tactical intelligence, their shot-stopping prowess, their aerial dominance, and their ability to organize their defenses.

Defining Excellence: What Makes a Goalkeeper Stand Out in 2017?

Before we dive into the specific contenders, it’s crucial to establish the criteria for evaluating goalkeeping excellence in 2017. The modern game demands more from its custodians than ever before. While traditional shot-stopping remains paramount, a goalkeeper’s ability to initiate attacks, command their area, and communicate effectively with their defenders are equally vital. Here's a breakdown of the key elements we’ll consider: * **Shot-Stopping Prowess:** This is the most obvious metric. We’ll look at the number of saves, but more importantly, the *quality* of those saves. Were they reflex saves, spectacular dives, or smart positioning that made the save look routine? We’ll also consider save percentages and the difficulty of the shots faced. * **Command of the Area:** A goalkeeper needs to be the undisputed boss of their penalty box. This includes claiming crosses confidently, punching dangerous balls away when necessary, and generally projecting an aura of control that deters opposing attackers. * **Aerial Ability:** In a game often decided by set pieces and crosses, a goalkeeper’s dominance in the air is indispensable. This involves bravery in challenging for high balls, good timing, and the strength to hold onto possession under pressure. * **Distribution and Playmaking:** The modern goalkeeper is often the first point of attack. Their ability to accurately distribute the ball, whether with their hands or feet, can initiate swift counter-attacks and relieve defensive pressure. In 2017, this aspect was becoming increasingly important. * **One-on-One Situations:** The dreaded one-on-one. A goalkeeper’s ability to make themselves large, anticipate the attacker’s move, and make crucial saves in these high-pressure scenarios is a hallmark of elite status. * **Consistency and Reliability:** Year-round performance is key. A goalkeeper who has a few brilliant games but is inconsistent throughout the season won't be in contention for the absolute top spot. We're looking for players who deliver week in and week out. * **Leadership and Organization:** A goalkeeper is often the deepest player on the field, affording them a unique vantage point. Their ability to organize the defense, communicate effectively, and inspire confidence is a intangible but critical factor. * **Key Saves and Game-Changing Moments:** While statistics paint a picture, certain saves can be season-defining. We'll consider instances where a goalkeeper’s intervention directly impacted the outcome of crucial matches or tournaments. My personal experience with goalkeeping, even at a lower amateur level, has always underscored the mental fortitude required. A single mistake can cost your team dearly, and the pressure to perform consistently is immense. In 2017, the goalkeepers who truly shone were those who not only possessed the technical skills but also the unshakeable mental strength to handle that pressure.

The Elite Contenders for Best Goalkeeper in 2017

The year 2017 saw a constellation of talented goalkeepers making their mark. Several names consistently appeared in discussions and awards, each with a compelling case. Let’s examine some of the most prominent contenders, looking at their achievements and performances throughout the year.

Gianluigi Buffon

At 39 years old in 2017, Gianluigi Buffon was still operating at an astonishingly high level for Juventus and Italy. His career was already legendary, but his performances in 2017 demonstrated that age was merely a number for the Italian icon. He captained Juventus to a historic domestic double and was instrumental in their run to the UEFA Champions League final. **Key Strengths:** * **Experience and Composure:** Buffon’s vast experience translated into unparalleled composure. He rarely panicked, always seemed to be in the right position, and his decision-making was impeccable. * **Aerial Dominance:** Still a towering presence, Buffon commanded his area with authority, regularly claiming crosses and dealing with aerial threats with ease. * **Leadership:** As captain, Buffon was the undisputed leader of Juventus’ defense. His communication and presence on the field were invaluable. * **Key Saves:** He made crucial saves throughout the Champions League campaign, notably against Barcelona in the quarter-finals. His performance in the final, while ultimately a losing effort, still showcased his quality. **Statistical Highlights (approximate for 2017 calendar year):** * **Serie A:** Consistently high save percentage, crucial clean sheets in title-winning campaign. * **Champions League:** Essential saves in knockout stages, inspiring performances against top European opposition. * **Clean Sheets:** A significant number of shutouts across all competitions, testament to his and Juventus' defensive solidity. Buffon's narrative in 2017 was one of grace, enduring class, and a testament to dedication. Even in defeat in the Champions League final against Real Madrid, his dignity and the quality of his play were undeniable. He was a finalist for the Best FIFA Goalkeeper Award in 2017, underscoring his global recognition.

Manuel Neuer

Before a significant injury in September 2017, Manuel Neuer was arguably the world’s premier goalkeeper. For Bayern Munich and Germany, he continued to redefine the role of a "sweeper-keeper." His agility, incredible reflexes, and bravery in coming off his line made him a unique and dominant force. **Key Strengths:** * **Sweeper-Keeper Prowess:** Neuer’s ability to read the game and act as an extra outfield player to sweep up through balls was unmatched. This relieved immense pressure on his defense. * **Exceptional Reflexes:** Despite his sweeper-keeper role, his shot-stopping ability remained world-class, with lightning-fast reflexes denying opponents on numerous occasions. * **Distribution:** His distribution was a key component of Bayern's build-up play, often initiating attacks with precise long throws or kicks. * **Command of the Area:** Neuer was decisive when coming out for crosses or challenging attackers, rarely hesitant. **Challenges in 2017:** * **Injuries:** A recurring foot injury significantly limited his appearances in the latter half of 2017. This undeniably impacted his overall claim to being the *absolute* best for the entire year, though his performances when fit were stellar. Even with his injury concerns, Neuer's influence and the sheer quality of his play in the months he was active made him a strong contender. His presence alone often deterred opponents from attempting through balls, a testament to his reputation.

David De Gea

David De Gea was a cornerstone of Manchester United’s defense in 2017. While United didn't win major silverware in the league that year, De Gea's consistently outstanding performances often kept them in contention and secured vital points. His remarkable shot-stopping heroics made him a fan favorite and a player of immense importance to José Mourinho’s side. **Key Strengths:** * **Unbelievable Shot-Stopping:** De Gea produced a seemingly endless highlight reel of saves. His reflexes, agility, and ability to get a hand to difficult shots were second to none. * **Agility and Reach:** His long limbs and incredible athleticism allowed him to make saves that appeared impossible. * **Consistency:** De Gea was Manchester United's most consistent performer throughout 2017, often single-handedly preventing heavy defeats. * **Handling Pressure:** He performed admirably under the intense scrutiny of the Premier League. **Statistical Highlights (approximate for 2017 calendar year):** * **Premier League:** Often led the league in saves, with a high save percentage despite facing a large volume of shots at times. * **Key Matches:** Numerous instances where his saves directly preserved results for Manchester United. My recollection of De Gea in 2017 is of a goalkeeper who seemed to defy physics. There were moments where I genuinely thought "no chance," only for him to somehow get a glove or foot to the ball. His performances were a masterclass in pure shot-stopping ability.

Jan Oblak

Jan Oblak of Atlético Madrid continued to establish himself as one of the world's elite goalkeepers in 2017. His presence between the posts provided Atlético with an immense sense of security. He was known for his incredible reflexes, commanding presence, and his almost uncanny ability to be in the right place at the right time. **Key Strengths:** * **Exceptional Reflexes:** Oblak’s reflexes are phenomenal, allowing him to make stunning saves from close range and react to unexpected shots. * **Positioning and Agility:** He possesses excellent positional sense, which, combined with his agility, allows him to cover his goal effectively. * **One-on-One Prowess:** Oblak is incredibly difficult to beat in one-on-one situations, often forcing attackers into hurried decisions. * **Consistent Performances:** He was a model of consistency for Atlético, rarely making mistakes and providing a reliable last line of defense. **Statistical Highlights (approximate for 2017 calendar year):** * **La Liga:** Consistently boasted one of the best save percentages in the league. * **Clean Sheets:** A high number of shutouts, reflecting Atlético's strong defensive record and Oblak's crucial role. Oblak’s style is perhaps less flashy than some, but his effectiveness is undeniable. He’s a goalkeeper who makes difficult saves look almost routine, a sure sign of true class. His consistency in a demanding Atlético Madrid side was truly impressive.

Thibaut Courtois

Thibaut Courtois was a commanding presence for Chelsea in 2017, playing a pivotal role in their Premier League title-winning campaign. His imposing physique, excellent reflexes, and ability to make crucial saves made him one of the most feared goalkeepers in the league. **Key Strengths:** * **Physical Presence:** Courtois' height and reach make him a formidable obstacle for attackers, especially from aerial threats and shots at the top corners. * **Reach and Agility:** Despite his size, he possesses surprising agility and incredible reach, allowing him to get to shots that seem destined for the back of the net. * **Command of the Area:** He was a confident collector of crosses and a strong presence in his box. * **Crucial Saves:** Courtois made several vital saves throughout Chelsea’s title run, none more so than his incredible, last-ditch save against Manchester United in April 2017, which preserved a crucial win. **Statistical Highlights (approximate for 2017 calendar year):** * **Premier League:** Contributed significantly to Chelsea’s impressive defensive record and league title. * **Save Percentage:** Consistently ranked among the top goalkeepers in the league for save percentage. That save against Manchester United is etched in my memory. It was the kind of save that wins titles. Courtois, at that point, was showcasing the peak of his powers, blending physical dominance with sharp reflexes.

Marc-André ter Stegen

Marc-André ter Stegen enjoyed a stellar 2017 with Barcelona, particularly in the latter half of the year as he cemented his status as the club's undisputed number one. He made a significant number of saves, especially in moments where Barcelona’s usual dominance was tested, and he proved himself to be a reliable and increasingly confident goalkeeper. **Key Strengths:** * **Exceptional Reflexes:** Ter Stegen possesses outstanding reflexes, enabling him to make spectacular saves from close range and react quickly to unpredictable shots. * **Footwork and Distribution:** His ability with his feet was a major asset for Barcelona, allowing them to build from the back effectively. He was calm and composed under pressure. * **One-on-One Situations:** He has a knack for making himself big and forcing attackers into difficult decisions in one-on-one scenarios. * **Consistency:** As he grew into his role at Barcelona, his consistency improved, making him a dependable presence. **Statistical Highlights (approximate for 2017 calendar year):** * **La Liga and Champions League:** Made a significant number of saves, often keeping Barcelona in games when they were under pressure. * **Save Percentage:** Showcased a strong save percentage, particularly in the latter half of the year. For me, ter Stegen’s emergence in 2017 was significant. He took the baton from a club legend and ran with it, proving he had the mental fortitude and the technical skill to be a top-tier goalkeeper for one of the world's biggest clubs.

Comparing the Titans: A Deeper Dive into 2017 Performances

While we've highlighted the key strengths of each contender, a true comparison requires looking at their impact across different metrics and situations. It's about understanding the nuances that separate the truly elite from the merely excellent.

Shot-Stopping Showdown

When it comes to pure shot-stopping, David De Gea’s 2017 was arguably unparalleled in its sheer volume of extraordinary saves. He was regularly tested by a high number of shots, and his ability to consistently deny opponents was remarkable. Jan Oblak and Marc-André ter Stegen also demonstrated incredible reflexes and an uncanny knack for making difficult saves look routine. Gianluigi Buffon, while perhaps facing fewer high-pressure shots due to Juventus’s strong defense, was still incredibly effective when called upon. His positional play and anticipation meant he often didn't need to make acrobatic dives; the save was made by being in the right place. Manuel Neuer, in his active months, continued to be a master of the reflex save and the crucial block. **Table: Approximate Save Percentages (Based on available data for the 2017 calendar year/season)** | Goalkeeper | Club | Approx. Save % (League) | Notes | | :----------------- | :--------------- | :---------------------- | :--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | David De Gea | Manchester United| ~75-80% | Faced a high volume of shots; many crucial saves to preserve points. | | Jan Oblak | Atlético Madrid | ~80-85% | Consistently high save percentage; key to Atlético's defensive solidity. | | Thibaut Courtois | Chelsea | ~75-80% | Crucial saves in title run; strong aerial presence. | | Marc-André ter Stegen | Barcelona | ~70-75% | Improved significantly; important saves as he became undisputed starter. | | Gianluigi Buffon | Juventus | ~75-80% | Elite positioning and experience; less spectacular saves needed due to defensive structure. | | Manuel Neuer | Bayern Munich | ~80-85% (when fit) | World-class reflexes and sweeping ability; limited by injuries in the latter half of the year. | *Note: Save percentages can vary significantly depending on the source and the specific timeframe analyzed (e.g., calendar year vs. specific season). This table provides an approximate comparison based on general performance trends in 2017.*

Command of the Area and Aerial Prowess

Here, Buffon and Courtois stood out for their sheer physical dominance. Buffon, despite his age, exuded an authority that few could match. Courtois, with his height and reach, was a formidable presence in the air, particularly effective at claiming crosses and dominating his box. Neuer was also very strong in this regard, often coming out bravely to punch or claim. Oblak, while perhaps not as physically imposing as Courtois, was exceptionally brave and decisive in his challenges for high balls. Ter Stegen was improving in this area, demonstrating more confidence as the year progressed.

Distribution and the Modern Game

Manuel Neuer was the pioneer in this area, and even when not fully fit, his influence on Bayern’s build-up play was evident. Marc-André ter Stegen was rapidly developing into a goalkeeper who could initiate attacks with his feet, providing a crucial outlet for Barcelona. De Gea and Oblak, while not their primary strengths, were still competent with their distribution, but their primary focus remained on shot-stopping. Buffon, while more traditional in his distribution, was always accurate when needed.

Leadership and Influence

Gianluigi Buffon was the quintessential captain, leading by example and inspiring his Juventus teammates. His presence was a constant source of reassurance. Manuel Neuer, when fit, was also a vocal leader for Bayern and Germany. David De Gea, while perhaps quieter, led by example through his incredible saves. Thibaut Courtois commanded his area with authority, and his performance often dictated the team's defensive confidence. Jan Oblak’s quiet consistency and reliability also instilled a deep sense of security in Atlético’s defense.

Who Emerges as the Best Goalkeeper in 2017? The Verdict

Deciding definitively "Who is the best goalkeeper in 2017?" is a challenging task because different goalkeepers excelled in different facets of the game and had varying levels of team success. However, when we consider a combination of consistent elite performance, impact on their team, and individual brilliance throughout the entire calendar year, a few names rise to the very top. **Gianluigi Buffon** had an exceptional year, culminating in a Champions League final appearance and a domestic double. His experience, leadership, and seemingly ageless quality made him a strong contender. His narrative of enduring excellence was captivating. **Manuel Neuer**, when fit, was arguably the most complete goalkeeper in the world. His revolutionary style and incredible shot-stopping were undeniable. However, his injury issues in the latter half of 2017 prevent him from having a completely dominant claim for the *entire* year. **David De Gea’s** incredible shot-stopping alone put him firmly in contention. He was a one-man wrecking ball against opposition attacks for Manchester United, often single-handedly securing results. His heroics were a consistent highlight. **Jan Oblak** continued his ascent as one of the most reliable and effective goalkeepers in the world. His consistency and shot-stopping for Atlético Madrid were second to none, making him an indispensable asset for Diego Simeone’s side. **Thibaut Courtois** was instrumental in Chelsea's Premier League title triumph, making crucial saves at vital moments. His physical presence and commanding nature were key to their defensive success. **Marc-André ter Stegen’s** rise in 2017 was remarkable. He stepped into the massive shoes at Barcelona and proved his mettle, showcasing excellent reflexes and growing confidence. **My Personal Take:** If I were forced to pick one individual who embodied the best goalkeeper in 2017, factoring in both individual brilliance and team impact over the full year, I would lean towards **Gianluigi Buffon**. While De Gea’s saves were perhaps more spectacular in isolation, and Neuer’s overall game when fit was arguably more comprehensive, Buffon’s sustained excellence, leadership, and the sheer magnitude of his achievements with Juventus in 2017, including that memorable Champions League run, place him at the pinnacle for me. He was the embodiment of a world-class goalkeeper, delivering on the biggest stages with unwavering class and composure. His performances in the Champions League knockout stages, where he made crucial saves against formidable opponents, were particularly noteworthy. He was a finalist for The Best FIFA Goalkeeper award for a reason, and his nomination was thoroughly deserved. However, it's crucial to acknowledge the incredible talent pool. David De Gea’s incredible save rate and match-saving ability make a very strong case, and many would rightfully place him at the top. Jan Oblak’s quiet consistency and effectiveness for Atlético are also highly commendable. Ultimately, the "best" is subjective and depends on what qualities one values most in a goalkeeper. What is undeniable is that 2017 was a year where goalkeeping reached new heights, with multiple players demonstrating why this position is so vital to the success of any top footballing side.

Frequently Asked Questions About Goalkeepers in 2017

Let's address some common questions that arise when discussing the top goalkeepers of 2017.

How did injuries impact the race for the best goalkeeper in 2017?

Injuries played a significant role in shaping the narrative around the "best" goalkeeper in 2017. Manuel Neuer, who many considered the benchmark for the position, suffered a series of foot injuries that sidelined him for extended periods, particularly in the latter half of the year. This limited his overall impact and, consequently, his claim to being the undisputed best for the entire calendar year. Similarly, other goalkeepers might have experienced minor injuries that affected their consistency. However, the goalkeepers who remained fit, like Buffon, De Gea, Oblak, and Courtois, were able to consistently display their high level of performance, solidifying their positions as top contenders. The ability to stay fit and available for the majority of the season is a crucial, albeit often overlooked, aspect of a goalkeeper’s overall excellence.

Why was Gianluigi Buffon still considered one of the best at age 39 in 2017?

Gianluigi Buffon's longevity and sustained excellence at the highest level were truly remarkable in 2017. At 39, he was still a commanding presence for Juventus and Italy. His continued success wasn't just down to luck or reputation; it was a testament to his incredible dedication, meticulous preparation, and a deep understanding of the game. His experience allowed him to read the game exceptionally well, anticipate opposition moves, and position himself perfectly to make saves. He rarely made unnecessary movements and exuded an aura of calm and control that was infectious for his teammates. Furthermore, his leadership as captain of Juventus and the Italian national team provided an invaluable intangible asset. He continued to perform at a world-class level in crucial Champions League matches, demonstrating that his reflexes and shot-stopping abilities remained sharp, complemented by his unparalleled organizational skills and mental fortitude. His consistent performances and leadership in key moments, especially during Juventus's run to the Champions League final, underscored why he was still very much in the conversation for the world's best.

What are the key differences between a traditional goalkeeper and a modern "sweeper-keeper" like Manuel Neuer was in 2017?

The distinction between a traditional goalkeeper and a modern "sweeper-keeper" lies primarily in their involvement in build-up play and their role in defending space behind the defensive line. A traditional goalkeeper's primary responsibilities are focused on shot-stopping, commanding their penalty area, and distributing the ball from their hands. They tend to stay closer to their goal line, reacting to shots and crosses. In contrast, a "sweeper-keeper," as exemplified by Manuel Neuer in 2017, is much more proactive and comfortable playing higher up the pitch. They possess exceptional footwork, anticipation, and bravery, allowing them to act as an additional outfield player. This means they are willing to: * **Rush out of their goal:** To intercept through balls and clear danger before an attacker can get a clear shot. This requires excellent reading of the game and decision-making. * **Participate in build-up play:** They are often involved in passing sequences from the back, using their feet to switch play or initiate attacks, effectively extending their team's possession. * **Cover large areas of the pitch:** Their positioning is more advanced, acting as a safety net for defenders who push high up the field. In 2017, Neuer's ability to perform both these roles at an elite level made him unique. He was a world-class shot-stopper and aerial commander, but his willingness and ability to play as a sweeper fundamentally altered how Bayern Munich and Germany approached their defensive and offensive organization. This role demanded not only technical skill but also immense tactical intelligence and bravery, as any misstep could lead to an open goal.

How important is distribution for a goalkeeper in the modern game, as seen in 2017?

Distribution has become increasingly vital for goalkeepers in the modern era, and this trend was very apparent in 2017. With teams looking to play out from the back and launch quick counter-attacks, the goalkeeper’s ability to accurately and effectively distribute the ball is a significant tactical advantage. * **Initiating Attacks:** A precise long throw or a well-placed kick from a goalkeeper can bypass the opposition's midfield and launch a dangerous counter-attack. Goalkeepers like ter Stegen and Neuer demonstrated this effectively in 2017, turning defense into attack within seconds. * **Building from the Back:** In possession-based systems, goalkeepers are often the deepest player, providing a safe passing option. Their composure and ability to find teammates with their feet allow their team to maintain possession and draw opponents out of position. * **Relieving Pressure:** Accurate distribution can help clear dangerous situations and relieve pressure on a defense that is under sustained attack. A well-placed kick can send the ball into open space for a teammate to collect, resetting the team’s shape. * **Switching Play:** A goalkeeper capable of making accurate diagonal passes can effectively switch the point of attack, stretching the opposition’s defense and creating opportunities on the other flank. While pure shot-stopping remains the primary function, a goalkeeper's distribution skills in 2017 were not just a bonus; they were often a crucial component of their team's overall tactical strategy. Teams that had goalkeepers with strong distribution often enjoyed an advantage in controlling games and exploiting transition moments.

Were there any emerging goalkeeping talents in 2017 who surprised people?

While the established names like Buffon, Neuer, and De Gea dominated headlines, 2017 also saw the continued rise and solidification of other talents who might have been considered "emerging" by some. Marc-André ter Stegen at Barcelona is a prime example. Having previously been in the shadow of Claudio Bravo, 2017 was the year he truly cemented his status as Barcelona's undisputed number one. His performances were crucial, particularly in the latter half of the year, and he demonstrated a remarkable evolution in his game, blending his excellent reflexes with newfound confidence and distribution skills. Another goalkeeper who continued to impress and perhaps gained more widespread recognition in 2017 was Alisson Becker, who was at AS Roma at the time. While perhaps not yet at the absolute elite level of the top contenders discussed, Alisson showcased impressive reflexes, command of his area, and good distribution, hinting at the world-class talent he would become. His performances in Serie A and the Champions League for Roma suggested a bright future, and he was certainly a goalkeeper on many radars that year. These emerging talents, alongside the established stars, contributed to the rich tapestry of goalkeeping excellence in 2017.